Page:The Complete Works of Henry George Volume 3.djvu/159

 n.

THE "REDUCTION TO INIQUITY."

BY HENRY GEORGE.

" ~TN this paper it has not "been my aim to argue," says _I_ the Duke of Argyll, in concluding his article entitled " The Prophet of San Francisco." It is generally waste of time to reply to those who do not argue. Yet, partly because of my respect for other writings of his, and partly because of the ground to which he invites me, I take the first opportunity I have had to reply to the Duke.

In doing so, let me explain the personal incident to which he refers, and which he has seemingly misunder- stood. In sending the Duke of Argyll a copy of " Prog- ress and Poverty," I intended no impertinence, and was unconscious of any impropriety. Instead, I paid him a high compliment. For, as I stated in an accompanying note, I sent him my book not only to mark my esteem for the author of " The Reign of Law," but because I thought him a man superior to his accidents.

I am still conscious of the profit I derived from " The Reign of Law," and can still recall the pleasure it gave me. What attracted me, however, was not, as the Duke seems to think, what he styles his "nonsense chapter." On the contrary, the notion that it is necessary to impose restrictions upon labor seems to me strangely incongruous, not only with free trade, but with the idea of the domi-

�� �