Page:Sacred Books of the East - Volume 3.djvu/487

 ancient books, in the reigns of the emperors Wăn and King, 179–141.

The copy in the ancient text was derived from the tablets found in the wall of the Confucian house in the time of the emperor Wû ( 140–87), and is commonly said to have been deciphered, as in the case of the tablets of the Shû, by Khung An-kwo. An-kwo wrote a commentary himself on the Hsiâo, which does not appear in Hin's Catalogue, just as no mention is made there of his commentary on the Shû. We find it entered, however, among the books in the Sui Library with the following note:—'The work of An-kwo disappeared during the troubles of the Liang dynasty ( 502–556), and continued unknown till the time of Sui, when a copy was found in the capital, and came into the possession of a scholar called Liû Hsüan.' Hsüan made his treasure public, and ere long it was acknowledged by the court, while many scholars contended that it was a forgery of his own, and ascribed by him to An-kwo. Whatever opinion we may form on this matter, the discovery of the old text, and the production of a commentary on it by Khung An-kwo, can hardly be called in question.

It might be argued, indeed, that another copy in the old text was found in the first century In a memorial addressed about the Shwo Wăn dictionary to the emperor An, in  121, by Hsü Kung, a son of the author, he says that the Hsiâo King which his father used was  a copy of that presented, by 'a very old man of Lû,' to the emperor Kâo ( 86–74). Many Chinese critics, and especially Wang Ying-lin