Page:On translating Homer (1905).djvu/46

 *ciently antiquated to obtain pardon of the reader for its frequent homeliness'. 'I am concerned', he says again, 'with the artistic problem of attaining a plausible aspect of moderate antiquity, while remaining easily intelligible'. And again, he speaks of 'the more antiquated style suited to this subject'. Quaint! antiquated!—but to whom? Sir Thomas Browne is quaint, and the diction of Chaucer is antiquated: does Mr Newman suppose that Homer seemed quaint to Sophocles, when he read him, as Sir Thomas Browne seems quaint to us, when we read him? or that Homer's diction seemed antiquated to Sophocles, as Chaucer's diction seems antiquated to us? But we cannot really know, I confess, how Homer seemed to Sophocles: well then, to those who can tell us how he seems to them, to the living scholar, to our only present witness on this matter,—does Homer make on the Provost of Eton, when he reads him, the impression of a poet quaint and antiquated? does he make this impression on Professor Thompson or Professor Jowett. When Shakspeare says, 'The princes orgulous', meaning 'the proud princes', we say, 'This is antiquated'; when he says of the Trojan gates, that they

With massy staples And corresponsive and fulfilling bolts Sperr up the sons of Troy,

we say, 'This is both quaint and anti