Page:Notes and Queries - Series 9 - Volume 5.djvu/376

 368

NOTES AND QUERIES. [9* s. v. MAY g, im.

volume, in which he discusses the various works that have at any time been associated with his name. Most readers would be well content to accept the judgment of an expert like Prof. Skeat on the non-authenticity of these attributions ; but he prefers giving us the reasons which have guided his decision, and asks the reader to weigh and estimate them for himself. The intelligent student of English will find it well worth his trouble to do so, and will learn much by the way. The more superficial reader, who has no liking for minute points of textual criticism, will probably take the finished product, and not trouble himself with the chips and shavings of the literary workshop which were struck off in its making.

It is well known that poems by Lydgate, Hoccleye, Ros, Clanvowe, and sundry others, which, like wild geese, flew unclaimed of any man, have long been ascribed to Chaucer through the carelessness or ignorance of successive editors. These are here submitted to certain well-ascertained tests of true Chaucerian verse, drawn from fourteenth-century grammar, rimes, and pronunciation, and are found to be wanting. By this irrefragable internal evi- dence it is demonstrated that they could not possibly have come from, the hand of Chaucer. As to ' The Romaunt of the Rose, 5 Prof. Skeat is cer- tain, as against Prof. Lounsbury, that Chaucer is not responsible for Fragment B (11. 1706-5810), which he thinks written by some Northern imi- tator ; and with more confidence than in his larger edition throws doubts on his being the author of Fragment C (11. 5811-7698).

THE papers on astronomy which have from time to time appeared in the Edinburgh Review have usually been of first-rate excellence. The one on * The Evo- lution of the Stars ' in the April number is assuredly no exception. It will, we feel sure, have no little educative value. It is somewhere about forty years since Kirchhoff found " the key to the hieroglyphics of the solar spectrum " ; but still the greater number of well -instructed persons who have not made astronomy a special object of study have but vague notions as to the vast and far-reaching results which have already flowed from this wonderful dis- covery results which have entirely changed our estimate of the history and destiny of the stellar universe. The paper on Dean Milman is very interesting, and will be found especially so by those who had the pleasure of knowing him. The writer regards the Dean as a great historian. In this we are in entire agreement with him, though there is no doubt that at times he generalized somewhat rashly, and was not in every instance able to allow sufficiently for differences of time and states o moral feeling. We, on the other hand, do noi think the writer estimates Milman's verse so highly as it deserves. * Alexander Leslie and Prince Rupert ' has given us great pleasure. If there be in it no information which is absolutely new, it is none the less valuable, as it demonstrates that the men were real living creatures like ourselves, no mere figures on the great chessboard of war. We wish the writer had vouchsafed some explanatioi of Leslie's flight from Marston Moor. The Scottisl leader was no coward. We believe that he con ceived rightly, according to the information in hi possession that the armies of the Parliament ha< sustained a complete rout, and that his first duty was to rally his scattered forces. The pictur given of Prince Rupert is very effective. He was

ot a great soldier, but has seldom had justice meted out to him. He had to work under extra- rdinary difficulties. No leader of men who ever ived could have been successful, and at the same ime obedient to so vacillating a master. ' Cappa- ocian Discoveries' requires careful reading and o little previous knowledge of what has been done n our own time on the sites of the old empires hat had passed away ere Romulus emerged from he she -wolf's den. The Mongolian influence on arly civilization is, we are glad to find, dwelt upon s it deserves. ' Morris and Rossetti ' and l Religion n Greek Literature ' are both bright papers, which vill give pleasure to the reader.

THERE is nothing calling for especial note in the

Antiquary for April. Perhaps the most interesting

hing in the number is the account, by Mr. Thomas

Iheppard, of a Roman vase or urn, recently dug up

a a clay pit at Barton-on-Humber, Lincolnshire.

An illustration is given, which shows that it is an

xceedingly fine one.

THE Genealogical Magazine appeals only to those who are interested in genealogical subjects, and annot be regarded in the light of a magazine of jresent nuniber there are reproductions of the >rasses of Margaret, Lady Camoys, and Sir John jeventhorpe, given with accounts of theni that jannot fail to be of interest to a wide circle of eaders.
 * eneral antiquarian interest. Nevertheless, in the

to

We must call special attention to the following notices :

ON all communications must be written the name and address of the sender, not necessarily for pub- ication, but as a guarantee of good faith.

W T E cannot undertake to answer queries privately.

To secure insertion of communications corre- spondents must observe the following rules. Let each note, query, or reply be written on a separate slip of paper, with the signature of the writer and such aoTdress as he wishes to appear. When answer- ing queries, or making notes with regard to previous entries in the paper, contributors are requested to ut in parentheses, immediately after the exact eading, the series, volume, and page or pages to which they refer. Correspondents who repeat queries are requested to head the second com- munication " Duplicate."

J. HOLDEN MACMICHAEL. Brook's Market once existed between Leather Lane and Gray's Inn Lane (now Road), Holborn. Brook Street still survives.

ARGIVE ("Omissions from Pepys's 'Diary'"). We cannot print the passages sent.

E. BENSLY. Many thanks ; already elucidated.

W. R. CROW (" Forestry"). Apply to a scientific journal such as the Gardeners' CJironicle.

NOTICE.

Editorial Communications should be addressed to " The Editor of ' Notes and Queries ' "Advertise- ments and Business Letters to "The Publisher" at the Office, Bream's Buildings, Chancery Lane, E. C.

We beg leave to state that we decline to return communications which, for any reason, we do not print ; and to this rule we can make no exception.