Page:Hofstede de Groot catalogue raisonné, Volume 1, 1908.djvu/593

 IV PIETER DE HOOCH A COMPARATIVE TABLE FOR IDENTIFYING IN THIS CATALOGUE THE PICTURES DESCRIBED BY SMITH, AND BY HOFSTEDE DE GROOT (iN Oud Holland^ vol. X. 1892, p. 178). Note. To find the new number of a picture described by Sm., or by de G. (Hofstede de Groot), look for his number in the left-hand column ; the new number will then be in the same horizontal line in the second column if Sm. describes the picture in vol. iv., in the third column if Sm. describes it in his Supplement, in the fourth column if de G. describes it in Oud Holland, vol. x. Thus, to find Sm. 16, look for 16 in the left-hand column ; the new number of this picture, in the second column, is 6. Again, Sm. Suppl. 16 is now 304, the number given in the third column ; while de G. 16 is now 3, the number given in the fourth column. Sm. Sm. Suppl. DeG. Sm. Sm. Suppl. De G. I 268 = Sm. 3 C 1 ) 17 223^ 312 I 9 I 2 '95 27 C 1 ) 18 2 9 I 61 26 3 7i 41 I '9 17 ( 8 ) ( 9 ) 4 = Sm. 3 59 2 20 126 108 120 5 2 55 279 71 21 189 235 5 6 239 1 *3 286 22 35 = Sm. 51 (10) 7 1 66 121 173 23 1 9 and 5 2 = Sm. 53 IIO 8 ( 2 ) 23 ( 3 ) 2 4 ( n ) 298 (12) 9 3 158 ( 4 ) 25 i = Sm. 61 122 10 62 = Sm. 28 ( 5 ) 26 264 = Sm. 9 182 ii 30 = Sm. 36 ( 6 ) 27 292 = Sm. 63 (13) 12 66 = Sm. 31 265 28 182 161 II I 13 144 136 25 2 9 78 = Sm. 37 266 H 38 = Sm. 42 o 30 297 295 6 15 293 = Sm 47 308 31 2 124 124 16 6 34 3 32 23O 125 1 Two views of ruins, with falsa signatures, dated 1656 j now in the Suermondt Museum, Aix- la-Chapelle ; not by P. de Hooch. 2 By Vermeer. 3 A so-called Portrait of the Artist, in the collection of Van Limbeeck and Sigault, Amsterdam, 1834 ; not by P. de Hooch. a false signature ; not by P. de Hooch. It was also wrongly connected with Koedijck. Hooch ; now rightly attributed to Es. Boursse. 6 The Pearl Necklace, in the collection of A. Bredius, The Hague, is by P. Janssens. See Oud Holland, vol. ix. 1891, "The painter Janssens, a follower of P. de Hooch," by Hofstede de Groot, No. ii. 7 Interior, formerly in the Kunis Museum, Antwerp, is by Vrel. See Jahrbuch der kgl. preussischen Kunstsammlungen, 1903, The Koedijck Puzxle and its Solution, by C. Hofstede de Groot. 8 A Man smoking and a Maid-servant is by P. Janssens ; it was last seen in the sale of P. Foucart, Valenciennes, October 1898. See also Oud Holland list, No. 14. 9 The Good Housewife, with the false monogram " P. D. H.", in the collection of Otto Wesendonck, now exhibited at the Kaiser Friedrich Museum, Berlin, is by Es. Boursse. 10 A Woman Sewing, in the Darmstadt Museum, is attributed to Samuel van Hoogstraten. 11 A Girl sweeping a Room was by P. Janssens ; this is shown by the copy, made by C. R. Leslie in 1831, and sold at Christie's, January 14, 1899. See Oud Holland list, No. 13. 12 Woman Reading, in the Stadel Institute, Frankfort-on-Main, is by P. Janssens. See Oud Holland list, No. 7. 13 Interior, in the Glitza collection, Hamburg, is not by P. de Hooch.
 * A Couple at Music, in the Van der Hoop collection in the Rijksmuseum, Amsterdam, with
 * Woman at the Spinning-wheel, in the Rijksmuseum, Amsterdam ; bought in 1882 as a P. de