Page:HKSAR v. Tong Ying Kit (Verdict).pdf/32

-32- 86. Although he was discharged that very same evening, PW10 still had pain on his left side and on his leg. He therefore went for further treatment and was discharged on 3 July 2020.

87. Before the Defendant’s motorcycle crashing into his colleagues, PW11 (PC 10426) heard the sound of the motorcycle’s engine intensifying which to him meant acceleration. PW11 told us that when he saw the motorcycle overtake the Brown Car, he immediately shouted to the Defendant to stop and he had repeated it several times.

88. At that time, he was holding onto the edge of a plastic shield. However, when the motorcycle was driving past him, the force was so great that he was unable to hold the shield and it flew away.

89. PW11 identified on P5 the time when the shield was transferred from his left hand (his dominant hand) to his right hand, which was at 0012 to 0015. He disagreed that he had thrown his shield at the Defendant.

F.2.5 Driver of the Brown Car

90. PW12 (Mr Lau) was the driver of the private car which stopped at Jaffe Road. He said he did so because he saw policemen ahead of him. He also saw the Defendant’s motorcycle overtake his car at a high speed and it then crashed into the police ahead.