Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers: Series II/Volume IV/Defence Against the Arians/Additional Note

Additional Note on ''Apol. C. Arianos,'' &#167;50.

.

materials for an authentic list are (1) the names given by Athanasius, ''Apol. c.'' Ar. 50, previous to the lists of bishops from various provinces who signed the letter of the council when in circulation. These names, given with no specification of their sees, are 77 in number. (2) The list of signatures to the letter of the council to Julius, given by Hilary, Fragm. ii., 59 in number. The signatures to the letters discovered by Maffei and printed in Migne, ''Patr. Gr.'' xxvi. 1331, sqq. Of these, 26 sign (3) the council&#8217;s letter to the Mareotic Churches, and 61, in part the same, sign (4) the letter of Athanasius to the same (Letter 46 in this volume). These signatures comprise 30 names not given by Hilary, while those in (1) add six which are absent from (2) and (3) alike. This raises the total to 95. We add (5) Gratus of Carthage, present according to the Greek text of the Canons, although he afterward signed the letter in a local council of his own, like Maximin of Treveri, Verissimus of Lyons, and Arius of Palestine, who are therefore given by Athanasius in his second list (the former two being omitted from the first): also Euphrates of Cologne, who was sent by Constans to Antioch with the council&#8217;s decisions (Prolegg. ch. ii. &#167;6), and was therefore most likely present at the council itself. We thus get 97 in all.

This total is confirmed if we subtract from the &#8216;170 more or less&#8217; of ''Hist. Arian.'' 15 the 76 seceders to Philippopolis (Sabinus in Socr. ii. 16), 73 of whom sign their letter, given by Hilary. This leaves 94 &#8216;more or less,&#8217; so that the list now to be given, in elucidation of that of Athanasius, has strong claims to rank as approximately correct. The numbers after the names refer to the sources (1, 2, 3, 4, 5) specified above. 1. (1), See unknown; 2. (1, 3), Thessalonica in Macedonia; 3. (1, 4), Cypara (i.e. Cyparissus?) in Achaia; 4. (2), Montemnae (?) in Achaia; 5. (1, 2, 3), Larissa in Thessaly; 6. (1, 2, 3), Megara in Achaia; 7. (1, 4), Viminacium, by deputy; 8. (4), See unknown; 9. (1, 2, 4), Casiulo in Spain; 10. (1, 4), Pella, or Pallene in Macedonia; 11. (4), See unknown; 12. (1, 4), Peiabio (Petovio) in Pannonia; 13. (4), See unknown; 14. (1, 2, 3), of Palestine, See unknown (see note on Hist. Ar. 18); 15. (1, 2, 4), Gasa; 16. (1, 2, 3), [Petra in] Arabia; 17. (1, 2, 3, 4), Alexandria; 18. (1, 2, 3, 4), Plat&#230;a in Achaia; 19. (1, 2, 3), Diocletianapolis &#8220;in Macedonia&#8221; (really in Thrace); 20. (1, 2, 3), of Campania (? Naples); 21. (2, 4), Castrum Martis in Dacia Ripensis; 22. or &#8216;Chalbis&#8217; (1, 4), See unknown; 23. (1, 2, 4), Saragossa in Spain; 24. (2), Asapofebiae in Achaia (= Asopus), perhaps the &#8216;Socrates&#8217; of (1); 25. (4), Cydon in Crete; 26. (1, 2, 4), Tenedos; 27. (1, 2, 3), Elida (Elis?) in Achaia; 28. (1, 2, 3), Thrace, See unknown; 29. (or Domitianus) (1, 4), Acaria Constantias (possibly Castra Constantia = Coutances); 30. (1, 2, 3), Asturica in Spain; 31. (1, 2, 3), Nicopolis; 32. (1, 4), Opus in Achaia; 33. (4), See unknown; 34. (4), Cissamus in Crete; 35. (4 = in 2?), Heraclea (in Lucania? texts very corrupt); 36. (1?, 4), See unknown; 37. (1, 4), See unknown;, see below (97); 38. (2), Pannonia, See unknown; 39. (1, 2), &#8216;Procia de Cayndo&#8217; (corrupt); 40. (1, 4), Methone in Achaia; 41. (1, 2), Achia, See unknown; 42. (1, 2, 4), Emerita in Spain; 43. (1, 2), Aquileia; (see above (22); 44.  (1, 2, 4), Naissus; 45.  (1, 2, 3, 4), a Macedonia in Brevi(?) in Hil.;, see below (96); 46.  (1, 4), Tyrtana (?); , see above (31); 47.  (1, 4), Sicyai (?); 48.  (1, 2, 4), Hypata in Thessaly; 49.  (1, 2, 4), Beneventum in Campania; 50.  (3), See unknown; 51.  (1, 2, 3), Particopolis in Macedonia; 52.  (1, 2, 4), Scyros in Achaia; 53.  (1, 2, 4), of Thebes in Achaia (or Thera? see note to Letter 46); 54. (1, 4), See unknown;, see below (95); (2), see above (52); 55.  (1, 2, 3, 4), Hadrianople in Thrace; 56. (&#8216;Lucillus&#8217; Ath. twice) (1, 2, 4), Verona; 57. (1, 2, 4), Ulpiana in Dardania; 58. (2, 4, Marcellinus in 1), Ancyra; 59. (1, 2, 4), Siscia on the Save; 60.  (2, 4), Naupactus in Achaia; 61. (1, 4), See unknown; 62. (1, 2), Luca in Tuscany; 63. (i.e. ) (4), Treviri; 64.  (1, 4), Heraclea in Crete; 65.  (or Musaeus, 1, 2), Thebes in Thessaly; 66.  (4), Aeni in Thrace; 67. Osius, (1, 2, 3), Cordova; 68.  (1, 2, 4), Dium in Macedonia; 69.  (1, 2, 3, 4), Scupi in Dardania; 70. (1), See unknown; 71.  (1), See unknown; 72.  (1), See unknown; 73.  (1, 2, 3), Patrae in Achaia; 74.  (1, 2, 3, 4), Philippi in Macedonia; 75.  (1, 2, 4), Barcelona; 76.  (1, 2, 4), Milan; 77.  (1, 2, 4), Sardica; 78.  (1, 3), See unknown; 79.  (1), See unknown; 80.  (4), Chalcis in Thessaly (Euboea); 81.  (1, 2, 3), Ravenna;  (1), see above, no. 24; 82.  (1), See unknown; 83. (1, 2, 4), Canusium in Apulia; 84.  (1, 4), Hierapythna in Crete;  (2), see above (40); 85.  (1, 2, 4), Achaia (See uncertain from corruption of text); 86.  (1, 2, 3), &#8216;Scio&#8217; in Dacia Ripensis; 87.  (2, 4, text of latter gives &#8216;Broseus&#8217; corruptly), Lyons; 88.  (1, 2, 3), Capua; 89.  (1, 2), Aquae in Dacia Ripensis; 90.  1, 3, 4), Vertara in Africa; 91. (1, 2, 4), Brixia in Italy; 92. (1, 2, 4), Lychnidus or Lignidus in Dacia; 93. (1, 4), Horrea Margi in M&#339;sia; 94. (1, 4), See unknown; 95. (1, 4), Rome (by deputies); 96. (5), Carthage; 97. (5), Cologne.

The names, both of bishops and of sees, have suffered much in transcription, and the above list is the result of comparing the divergent errors of the various lists. The details of the latter will be found in the originals, and in the discussion of the Ballerini, on whose work (in Leonis M. Opp. vol. iii. pp. xlii. sqq.) our list is founded. In some cases the names of the see are clearly corrupt beyond all recognition. The signatures appended to the canons in the collections of councils, are taken (with certain uncritical adaptations) from the Hilarian list, with the addition, in some copies, of Alexander (3 supra), whose name, therefore, has probably dropped out of the Hilarian text in course of transmission.]