Author talk:Julia Crawford

Name
LOL -- though it looks like Annie at least is definitely a separate person.

Annie


 * "CRAWFORD, ANNIE" --Alan Goble The Complete Index to Literary Sources in Film (1999)

Julia


 * "Julia Crawford" --Shirlee Emmons, Wilbur Watkin Lewis, Researching the Song: A Lexicon (2008)

Louise


 * "Crawford, Louise Macartney" --Charles Dudley Warner, A Library of the World's Best Literature (2008)

Marion


 * "Marion Crawford" --w:User:Jmboothe, w:Kathleen Mavourneen (2004 article creation)
 * "Crouch stated that she was Mrs. Marion Crawford" --Florence Leniston Popular Irish Songs (1992)
 * "Mrs. Marion Crawford" The Month at Goodspeed's (1955) --

Annie/Julia


 * "the lyrics are usually attributed to a Mrs. Crawford, although whether this was Mrs. Annie Barry Crawford, an English poet, or Julia Crawford, the composer's County Cavan-born wife, is not clear." --W. H. A. Williams, &apos;Twas Only an Irishman's Dream: The Image of Ireland and the Irish in American Popular Song Lyrics, 1800-1920

Annie/Louise


 * "Crawford, Mrs. Louise [Macartney] [...] At. also to Mrs. Anne (Barry) Crawford" --Edith Granger An Index to Poetry and Recitations (1904)

Julia/Louise


 * "Julia [poss. Louise or Louisa]" "PI calls her Louisa Matilda Jane Crawford, but cites E. C. Stedman’s Victorian Anthology which gives her name as Louise Macartney Crawford" --Bruce Stewart, Ricorso: A Catalogue of Full-text Works on Ireland in the Internet Archive (2010)
 * "Julia Crawford was born Louise Matilda Jane Montague" --Sean McMahon, Rich and Rare (1984)

Julia/Marion


 * "There is a debate at this late date that the lyrics were provided by a woman named Marion Crawford. Time has passed and at this date, I am unable to determine with finality, the identity of the lyric writer.  But I assume that either Marion or Julia wrote the lyrics" --Ezra Edgar Carr, "Upon being self-hoodwinked" (2011)

Annie/Julia/Louise

—Beleg Tâl (talk) 00:45, 26 April 2017 (UTC)
 * "Crawford, Mrs. Julia (or L. M.) [...] may have been the Mrs. A. Crawford who published 'Stanzas' 1830?" --David James O'Donoghue, The Poets of Ireland (1893)

Assuming they're all separate people
If all the Crawford names are different people, what can we determine about them? —Beleg Tâl (talk) 16:36, 26 April 2017 (UTC)
 * Annie Barry Crawford is definitely someone else. Dates 1731-1801 per and, English poet per , and actress born in Bath per . I think it's also safe to say that this is not the same "Mrs. A. Crawford" whose Stanzas and other works appeared in London in 1830-1857 per.
 * Louisa Matilda Montagu was the daughter of Lt.-Col. George Montagu and Anne Courtenay. She married Matthew Crawford. She died on 29 December 1857. Her married name became Crawford. Born 1789 . Listed as Louisa-Matilda-Jane-Macartney (Montagu) Crawford in.
 * Julia Crawford born in Ireland, died "about 1855" per . As above, some believe Julia is a pseudonym of Louise.
 * Marion, no information at all besides the statement that Crouch identified this as the given name of "Kathleen Mavourneen"'s author.