Anglo-Saxon Riddles of the Exeter Book/Annotated/72

This riddle is somewhat related to the above, having a sort of secret writing instead of runes.

This looks at first like two different riddles; for it is not usual to solicit the answer twice. The two bracketed lines (4–5) are doubtless an interpolation by some overzealous copyist, to make everything more difficult. He used the simple old code of representing vowels by the alphabetically following consonants. Thus hwm (miscopied) is for homo, &lsquo;man,&rsquo; repeating man; mxlkfw f (also miscopied) is for mulier, repeating wiif, &lsquo;woman&rsquo;; qxxs is for equus, &lsquo;horse.&rsquo; For the rest, interpretations vary. Trautmann, for example, has the following: &ldquo;A man and his wife are seated on a horse; the man has a bird in his hand, the woman a dog on her arm and an unborn child inside her (or the man has the dog and the woman has the bird). The four feet are the horse&rsquo;s; the eight on its back are the child&rsquo;s, the bird&rsquo;s, and the dog&rsquo;s. The feet of the man and wife are not counted since they are neither underneath nor up above. The six heads and twelve eyes are those of the man, woman, child, dog, bird, horse.&rdquo; But he admits that difficulties remain. Another guess sees a boat with four oars and eight rowers and on board a horse, a man, a woman, a bird, and a dog. Or no bird, the wings being sails. A more elaborate interpretation is proposed by Erika von Erhardt-Siebold (PMLA [1948], 3–6). A party of hunters is returning home in a boat with two dogs and the game. The boat had four feet underneath (four oars) and eight above (four oarsmen); the boat had two wings (bird being a conventional metaphor for ship). The twelve eyes were those of the four oarsmen, the dog, and the bird which had been killed. Besides this there was the likeness of a horse (now the boat itself) and a man (as on horseback), and a dog and bird literally. The form of a woman is probably an ornamental design or figurehead of the boat. Thus Mrs. von Erhardt-Siebold with slight changes.